17 Jan 2026 10:03:26
Thread below got me thinking about our summer signings so thought I would rate them individually out of 10 rather than plucking a number out of the air for overall transfer window. Note I have taken price into account in ratings (was interesting to remind self of these! ) and done in chronological order. !

nmecha (free) 6.5
Bijol (£15m) 10
Bournauw. (£5m) 8
GG (£10m) 10
Longstaff (£12m) 5
Stach (£17m) 10
Perri (£16m) 2
DCL (free) 10
Okafor (£17m) 5’.5
Justin (£8m) 7.5

Average 7.5
Average (outfield only) 8.0

I think we had a very good window.

1.) 17 Jan 2026
17 Jan 2026 11:37:35
Perri 2 is a bit harsh.
I would bump Nmecha to 7.5 considering his goal contributions:time played.

Otherwise I agree.

If the players keep this form or keep improving, we could make a lot of money in summer on selling people for upgrades. Obviously keep Bijol, GG, JJ, Stach and DCL.
Buy a better goalie.

2.) 17 Jan 2026
17 Jan 2026 11:56:06
Great post, think I’d give Okafor an extra point but otherwise very good.

3.) 17 Jan 2026
17 Jan 2026 12:31:19
Generous with Perri
And okafar needs to be more consistent as has the talent.

4.) 17 Jan 2026
17 Jan 2026 15:02:57
Not saying Perri has been good, but 2 is a little harsh, I'd maybe give him 3.5. Also I'd bump Okafor up to say 8.5 and Justin to 9, and drop Stach to 9. I'll leave you to recalculate the average.