29 Nov 2019 11:12:29
Does anyone actually rate any of Phil Hay, Noel Whelan or Danny Mills as pundits on Leeds United. all 3 just seem to be making money relentlesly searching
for and talking for the sake of talking about Leeds United, often negatively and seemingly with very little genuine insight or genuine inside knowledge.
29 Nov 2019 12:09:04
Of the 3, I have most faith in Hay, but that is still limited.
29 Nov 2019 12:37:59
Whelan and Mills is commentary and punditry which you always take with a grain of salt. Hay though has enjoyed good relations with the club for many years and is therefore more reliable. However, he's no longer the correspondent with the YEP so you have to wonder in what capacity is he trying to feed us? Why is he even bothering? Why isn't the new guy at the YEP Smyth doing all of that? What's the point in Smyth if Hay is still reporting? Is Hay stepping on toes? Current arrangement looks weird so I'd trust Hay less than before. If QSI takeover, no doubt the entire communication regime shall be revamped.
29 Nov 2019 13:11:47
Do not listen to them to be honest, they have opinions and conjecture but my dog knows as much about LUFC as these guys. Its just another way of debating to be fair. You either agree or disagree.
29 Nov 2019 13:11:17
You should ask these questions to your YEP and blogging contacts George. Would be interesting to find out.
29 Nov 2019 13:35:34
i have never taken any notice of any of them, only place i come to for thoughts opinions and views is this site.